Posted by Waigerits(VIP) on December 22, 1999 at 05:07:34:

In Reply to: since none of the imms have not actually presented new info and it is as arolin says ... posted by Graham on December 22, 1999 at 04:53:33:

> denying him is just wrong.

> as zenan says further down...
> did he ask to go there?
> was he asked with the knowledge they were going there?
> did they get the item?
> did the try to get the item?

> was he just playing a character that happened to be going the same place as another character was interested in?
> Should we ban scarabaeus from hell? Nepenthe from Kuo-toa,Nimbus from battlefields,Twist from....well... should we?
> they are mixing character info surely if they go there? hell a non newbie walking around galadon in record time is sharing char info..

> he didn't try to cheat, he didn't ask to cheat
> oh and any time i saw shannagen he was dicking around on his own.

Well, at first I had the same opinion, but later changed my mind.
Let's say you have a level 20 char that is naked and cannot get
some fancy stuff. You log on your hero and other heroes invite you
to go somewhere where you happen to get some nice things that your
level 20 char could use. Also, you know that if you leave these
nice things to those other heroes they will pass them to your
level 20 char. This is similar to what happened. Shannagen, even
though he's not level 20, just couldn't go and get that item on
his own. But his another character could. With help or not, but it's
the same, it's getting items that your another character cannot get
himself. This is where rules work.

What I find bad in that case is that he was denied on sight without
any conversation with an immortal that did it. That just doesn't seem
right to me.

Follow Ups:

• I agree....I do not think a necro should just be given his items by cabalmates...he should have to go there himself and get it...NT Someone 08:27:16 12/23/99 (0)

Post a Followup